The dynamic duo of Grant Robertson and Jacinda Ardern – now termed ‘Gracinda’ on social media – could well be the Labour Party’s best bet for recovering from its 2014 electoral nadir. The two are probably the most dynamic of the leadership candidates on offer, and have real talent. There will be a strong temptation amongst the membership to choose their ‘new generation’ message. But there are also some major problems with putting ‘Camp Robertson’ in charge of Labour. While they might have more style than their counterparts, some commentators are pointing to their lack of substance as being a worry for the party’s future.
Labour has a greyness problem at the moment (summed up in my last column, Are Labour's 'pale, male, stale' days done?) and Robertson and Ardern are well placed to insert some colour and competence into the leadership. There should be no doubt that Grant Robertson is an extremely able campaigner and operator. Amongst the various candidates for leader, he’s definitely the ‘smartest in the room’ when it comes to political strategy and playing the parliamentary political ‘game’. He has the lobbying background and skills, the media-savvy, and the strong ability to form alliances amongst disparate political factions. He’s also one of the most ambitious politicians around. If he became leader – which he’s clearly extremely hungry for – he will also be absolutely driven to achieve his lifelong ambition of becoming prime minister. The necessary electoral rebuild of Labour will be well served by these qualities.
So although other candidates like Andrew Little appear to be ahead of Robertson in this race, Robertson’s abilities to turn this situation around shouldn't be underestimated.
Robertson’s deliberate blandness
Part of Robertson’s political strength is his strong pragmatism and sense of which way the wind is blowing. In this way, he’s possibly more like John Key than any other politician around. But this can be easily parodied, as seen in Toby Manhire’s brilliantly funny column, Labour in safe and bloody hands. Here’s Robertson according to Manhire: ‘I often reflect unschemingly on these ideas of an evening, while drinking rugby and playing beer. The Labour Party needs a leader who can embody this new generation, but who has also been around the traps for as long as anyone can remember. New but old. Insider and outsider. Bad supermarkets, good beer and rugby. Reconnect, rebuild, refocus, relax, revert, resuscitate, rerebuild, rerugby and rebeer’.
There is also come concern about the extent to which Robertson takes his cautious pragmatism. The must-read item of the day is Phil Quin’s blog post, Robertson's 'safety-first' leadership pitch fraught with risk. Quin – who has been a longtime Labour Party activist – complains that Robertson only ever seems to make vacuous statements: ‘It's impossible to disagree with anything Grant Robertson says. That's a problem’. Pointing to Robertson’s latest statement of his values for leadership, Quin seeks to find something tangible amongst it all: ‘The answer is nothing; nothing, that is, beyond the lukewarm fuzzies you get by placing inoffensive words in a pleasing formation. You could rewrite the phrase "government blah blah communities blah blah" without sacrificing an ounce of substance or impact. There is nothing especially egregious about this one anodyne phrase out of hundreds like it, but it’s a decent example of a much broader problem – with political communication generally, and with Grant Robertson's bid for the Labour leadership in particular’.
Quin says that Robertson’s ‘knack for pleasant-sounding but hollow eloquence’ is partly down to his background as a diplomat and argues that, by contrast, politics needs greater conflict and clarity, which is a problem for him: ‘Robertson’s muddled pandering on the gay question, as well as pretty much everything else, points to a deeper weakness: it is not an aversion to the opposite sex that calls into doubt his ability to lead Labour out of the wilderness, but a chronic and debilitating aversion to risk’.
Another leftwing blogger – and Wellington policy analyst – also finds fault in Robertson’s deliberate blandness, saying that this ‘lack of substance is alarming’ – see Fundamentally Useless’ Give us some substance, Grant. The blogger says he wants Robertson to win the leadership, but complains that his approach is ‘candy floss politics. Lots of colour, little meaning’. Jacinda Ardern is also heavily criticised in the blog post as having achieved little in her political career.
See also, Duncan Garner’s Robertson and Ardern need to stand for something.
Chris Trotter has also questioned whether Robertson and Ardern are bold enough to save Labour at the moment – see the TV3 article (and 4-minute interview), Trotter: Labour could learn from Don Brash. He says that Robertson ‘is very much in that cautious, incremental mode that Helen Clark made so successful in terms of her own career’. But this lack of boldness might not be, Trotter says, what Labour needs right now.
But Ardern is proclaiming that they will indeed be bold – see Radio NZ’s Labour needs bold ideas says Ardern. And to counter the ‘beltway’ tag, see Stacey Kirk’s Jacinda Ardern bites back at 'Beltway babies' branding.
Gracinda’s strategic alliances
Some have called the inclusion of Jacinda Ardern as Robertson’s ‘running mate’ a ‘strategic masterstroke’. But could Ardern end up being leader herself, if not prime minister? That’s the prediction posed today by Rachel Smalley, who says ‘Ardern is Labour's best hope for the future and could be the MP who one day leads Labour back into government’ – see: Ardern is Labour's best hope long-term. Ardern’s positives are lauded: ‘She is popular both outside of the party and within. She exudes a warmth and an intelligence, and it appears she is in politics for the policy and not for the power’.
There will be further interesting manoevers from Robertson, especially with his ability to forge stratetic alliances. After all, as Claire Trevett has pointed out, ‘Robertson is regarded as the effective head of the ABC (Anyone But Cunliffe) faction’ – see: Factions and females - F words dog Labour. And for years he has cultivated support on the right of Labour’s caucus, as well as strong friendships with the likes of Trevor Mallard and Annette King.
Of course the election of David Shearer as Labour leader in 2011 was in large part due to the ABCs and Grant Robertson. And further machinations can be expected over the next month. It will be interesting to see which political figures endorse Robertson for leader. Michael Cullen has already done so, as has Darien Fenton. As Trevett points out regarding the latter, ‘She is a prominent union figure and Camp Robertson clearly hopes her endorsement will ensure rival Andrew Little does not get the clean sweep he is hoping for among the unions’.
But surely Robertson will be less keen on public endorsements from the likes of Mallard, Cosgrove or Goff. On the other hand, others in the so-called Wellington beltway are coming forward with enthusiasm for Robertson. For example, former VUWSA President Fleur Fitzsimmons has penned on The Standard, A paean about Grant Robertson. Other endorsements are published by Robertson on his new website, http://www.grantrobertson.co.nz/
Finally, in terms of the ‘Gracinda’ Twitter tag, the orginator seems to have been Philip Matthews (@secondzeit), who tweeted yesterday ‘Team Gracinda. Team Ardertson’. Patrick Gower (@patrickgowernz) has picked up on this, tweeting: ‘Grant & Jacinda - "Gracinda". Political "twofer"/2-for-1 deal. Buy Grant, get Jacinda free! #Gracinda’. For a lot of diverse opinions and analysis on the leadership combo – see my blog post, Top tweets about #Gracinda.
Today’s content
UN Security Council seat
Murray McCully: UN seat doesn't mean Iraq action
TVNZ: Security Council seat won't harm NZ foreign policy - UN Ambassador
Bernard Manning (Herald): NZ independence important at UN - Jim McLay
Tracy Watkins (Stuff): No cushy ride ahead at UN
Integrity Talking Points: Can treating UN delegates ever be justifiable?
Tracy Watkins (Stuff): Cocktail guests gave UN hint
Audrey Young (Herald): NZ must now walk the tough talk of UN campaign
Dom Post: Editorial: Let's live up to independent promise
Southland Times: Editorial: NZ takes its place at the table
Press: Editorial: UN win useful but limited
Damien Rogers (Herald): Raft of complexities for small country to navigate
Audrey Young (Herald): UN choices may strain friendships, McCully says
ODT: Editorial: Now, the real work begins
Grant Duncan (Policy Matters): New Zealand can do more for the humanitarian crisis in Ukraine
Patrick Gower and Simon Shepherd (TV3): Security Council seat a second chance for New Zealand
Stacey Kirk (Stuff): NZ's UN Security Council win praised
Newswire/TV3: UN Security Council win unites Govt, Opposition
No Right Turn: Bugger
Adam Bennett (Herald): Key: NZ will have 'loud voice' on Security Council
Audrey Young (Herald): UN Security Council victory: Team New Zealand in its truest sense
Rob Salmond (Polity): Well done NZ
Labour Party
Phil Quin (Pundit): Robertson's 'safety-first' leadership pitch fraught with risk
Stacey Kirk (Stuff): Jacinda Ardern bites back at 'Beltway babies' branding
Radio NZ: Labour needs bold ideas says Ardern
Rachel Smalley (Newstalk ZB): Ardern is Labour's best hope long-term
TV3: Trotter: Labour could learn from Don Brash
TVNZ: Jacinda Ardern: Judge me on my competency not my age
Felix Marwick (Newstalk ZB): Robertson coy on who should step aside
Stacey Kirk (Stuff): Union backs Andrew Little for Labour leadership
Audrey Young (Herald): EPMU backs Little in leadership contest
RadioLive: Ardern as deputy 'risky' move – Mike Williams
The Standard: Labour’s Leadership campaign heats up
Pete George (Your NZ): Robertson and Ardern, Grant and Jacinda
Simon Day (Stuff): Labour needs new generation – Robertson
Tova O’Brien (TV3): Jacinda Ardern is Grant Robertson's preferred deputy in Labour leadership race
TVNZ: Grant Robertson sounds a warning to disloyal MPs
Felix Marwick (Newstalk ZB): Robertson coy on who should step aside
RNZ: Robertson says Ardern would be deputy
Stuff: Robertson picks Ardern as running mate
TVNZ: Labour names post-election review team
Stacey Kirk (Stuff): Ex-MP to head panel of inquiry
Newswire: Labour names team to review election loss
TVNZ: David Parker admits to 'glitches' in selling capital gains tax policy
Stacey Kirk (Stuff): Labour hopefuls trade policy blows
Brendan Manning (Herald): Labour leadership race: 'We've got to talk to NZers'
TVNZ: 'We should've been more clear about Internet Mana' - Grant Robertson
Pete George (Your NZ): David Parker – Standard Q & A
Newswire: Grant Robertson outlines ambitions
Mike Williams (Herald): David Parker's my pick of the bunch
Pete George (Your NZ): Labour leadership events and links
Ellipsister: Labour to the middle
Rodney Hide (Herald): Labour's answer? Let MPs choose
John Roughan (Herald): Labour's leadership vote matters to us all
The Standard: Sherman Cunliffe
James Griffin (Herald): Labour, I am your man
Kiwiblog: Guest Post: Can Labour ever again lead a governing coalition? – 3 scenarios
Andrew Gunn (Press): Parliament Pictures presents ... The Power-Hunger Games
Matt Rilkoff (Stuff): Buddy upstages Little
Irene Gardiner (Herald): NZ on Screen: Labour leaders of the past
Matthew Dallas (Manawatu Standard): Threat of Labour's favour spooks the horses
Herald: Shane Jones: From five-star hotels to state house
National Party
Vernon Small (Stuff): Political influence denied in Ede's work
Martyn Bradbury (Daily Blog): Jason Ede is back – but no media can interview him?
Herald on Sunday editorial: The Hon is all that's on for Collins
Matthew Beveridge (Social Media): The next three years: National
Chris Ford: National - the key reasons why they won
David Kennedy (Local Bodies): Secrets, Lies and Revelations
Strategic voting and electoral deals
Isaac Davison (Herald): Nats' strategic voting vital for Act
Keith Locke (Daily Blog): The politics of electorate accommodations
The Standard: Strategic voting
Opening of Parliament
Stacey Kirk (Stuff): Special WWI touches as Parliament opens
Peter Wilson (Newswire): Parliament set to open
Parliament Today: 51st Parliament To Be Commissioned
NZ intervention in Middle East
Adam Bennett (Herald): Any SAS activity under the radar for public
Arthur Chesterfield-Evans (ODT): Why NZ shouldn't go to war
Martin van Beynen (Press): The self-defeating nature of terror alerts
Scott Yorke (Imperator Fish): We must join the fight against Islamic State
The Standard: To arms!
Lynn Prentice (Standard):Let them go to war
Dom Post: Editorial: Wisdom won from worst kind of madness
Inequality
Kate Newton (RNZ): Struggling families eager for relief
Newswire: Kiwi welfare numbers increase
Thomas Heaton (Stuff): Govt 'playing the figures' on welfare
RNZ: Keep child poverty focus – Archbishop
No Right Turn: Treasury cherry-picks its data
Slightly Left of Centre: It simply isn’t their fault
Housing
Simon Collins (Herald): 'No point' in new state houses - Bill English
Simon Collins (Herald): Peters condemns move to sell state houses
Anthony Robins (Standard): No point in state houses
Catherine Harris (Stuff): NZ wealthy, but it's locked up in housing
Nicky Hager and Dirty Politics
Neil Ratley (Stuff): Hager fundraising goes global
Peter Aranyi (The Paepae): Read Nicky Hager’s search warrant
Martyn Bradbury (Daily Blog): Comparing Police action – Hager raid vs Roast Buster case
Media
Steve Braunias (Stuff): The secret diary of . . . Paul Henry
The Standard: The 4th estate & its pretenders
Press: Criticism of Radio NZ a storm in a breakfast teacup
Matthew Beveridge (Social Media): Twitter stats 17 October
TPPA
No Right Turn: TPPA would criminalise journalism
Tom Pullar- Strecker (Stuff): Kiwis may be hit by higher medicine costs
Brian Easton (Pundit): Dealing with Foreign Investors
Other
The Wireless: Should New Zealand change its flag?
James Shaw (Green blog): The OIA Abuse
TV3: NZ prepared for Ebola – Health Minister
Niko Kloeten (Stuff): Lawyer calls for wages protection
Alex Fensome (Stuff): Wipe your student loan: go bankrupt
Fran O'Sullivan (Herald): Treasury must front up over role in SCF debacle
Herald: Editorial: Arming police carries too many risks
Kelly Dennett (Stuff): Roast Busters inquiry drags on
Talia Shadwell (Stuff): Malaysian accused due back to face sex charges
Richard Meadows (Stuff): Kiwisaver whoopsie
Curwen Rolinson (Daily Blog): Guest blog: Leadership Transitions In Other Parties: A Short Guide