Quick fix bargaining pushes up WorkSafe conviction rate
The workplace safety regulator said to 'start high' with the aim of faster settlement on a discounted fine.
Under WorkSafe direction.
Brent Melville
Wed, 19 Jun 2024
Key points
- What’s at stake: Construction and other contractors said to be willing to enter a plea bargain rather than risk going to court and face significant financial impacts, being facilitated by WorkSafe lawyers.
- Background: Several companies have spoken to NBR about settling on plea bargains for perceived health and safety transgressions, effectively sidestepping legal process but artificially elevating the agency's hit rate.
- Main players: WorkSafe, Yakka Contracting, Ward Demolition, Duncan Cotterill, MBIE.
WorkSafe's high conviction rate of about 83% is largely attributable to scare tactics that lead to fast plea bargains, a leading lawyer says.
A number of companies spoken to by NBR have also confirmed it was "common practice" to plead guilty early in the piece, and pay a reduced fine under the
Want to read more? It's easy.
Choose your best value subscription option
Individual
Group membership
NBR Marketplace
Yearly Premium Online Subscription
NZ$499.00 / yearly
Monthly Premium Online Subscription
NZ$44.95 / monthly
Smartphone Only Subscription
NZ$24.95 / monthly
Premium Group Membership 10 Users
NZ$350+GST / monthly
$35 per user - Pay by monthly credit card debitPremium Group Membership 20 Users
NZ$600+GST / monthly
$30 per user - Pay by monthly credit card debitPremium Group Membership 50 Users
NZ$1250+GST / monthly
$25 per user - Pay by monthly credit card debitPremium Group Membership 100 Users
NZ$1875+GST / monthly
$18.75 per user - Pay by monthly credit card debitYearly Premium Online Subscription + NBR Marketplace
NZ$499.00 / yearly
Already have an account? Login
Brent Melville
Wed, 19 Jun 2024
Contact the Writer: bmelville@nbr.co.nz
News tip? Question? Typo? Let us know: editor@nbr.co.nz
© All content copyright NBR. Do not reproduce in any form without permission, even if you have a paid subscription.
Related News
Key points
- What’s at stake: Construction and other contractors said to be willing to enter a plea bargain rather than risk going to court and face significant financial impacts, being facilitated by WorkSafe lawyers.
- Background: Several companies have spoken to NBR about settling on plea bargains for perceived health and safety transgressions, effectively sidestepping legal process but artificially elevating the agency's hit rate.
- Main players: WorkSafe, Yakka Contracting, Ward Demolition, Duncan Cotterill, MBIE.
Related News
Quick fix bargaining pushes up WorkSafe conviction rate
Law,
104549